Okay, so I feel like I don't have to tell you that fictional stories (I'm talking about literature, film, television, the works) tend to be told from a male perspective, and when they aren't, when a woman is at the helm, they're trivialized and infantilized. There's a reason why when we look back at some of the most iconic roles (heroes, villains, you name it) they seem to be men. We just don't realize it. But girlfangs is not a criticism blog, so I'm segueing into something good that comes from this trend: genderswaps.
I love genderswaps. Not only are they fun, but they're undeniable proof that biological sex does not a more compelling character make. Just because you're a male does not mean your story gets to be more accessible than mine, and these ladies prove it. Yes, genderswapping works both ways, and female characters can be made male, but for the purposes of girlfangs (and my own personal interest) here, in no particular order, are my top five favorite genderswaps: male to female.
![]() |
| edit by vesprs.tumblr.com |
- Kara Thrace, Battlestar Galactica. Now in the original BSG from the 1980s, Lieutenant Starbuck was hot-headed, red-blooded, heavy-drinking, cigar-smoking, sex-having, gambling male. And when BSG was reimagined in the early 2000s, Lieutenant Starbuck was turned into Kara "Starbuck" Thrace, a hot-headed, red-blooded, heavy-drinking, cigar-smoking, sex-having, gambling female. I love Kara Thrace. She's still the star pilot she was in the original series, and she has so much heart and growth over the series. Starbuck (her pilot call sign, by the way) has been described as "one of television's most complex, ever-evolving characters," and this is entirely after her recreation as a female in the reimagined BSG. She's one of the most incredible characters in television, male or female, and even if you aren't into sci-fi, I'd recommend this series for her alone.

edit by intotardis.tumblr.com - Joan Watson, Elementary. This is a relatively new character on the scene. Joan Watson is the female (of color, I might add!!!) reimagining of the ubiquitous John Watson, Sherlock Holmes' sidekick- but let's be real, in Elementary, it's definitely Joan that wears the pants in this relationship. Now Elementary got a lot of shit for casting Lucy Liu (who is better than you in every single way, lest you forget) as John Watson, but I'm not gonna talk about the ignorant vomit that spewed from peoples' mouths. Instead, I'm going to tell you about how Joan Watson is a character with all the nuances and sensitivity that, say, Martin Freeman or Jude Law lack in their tired portrayals. I'm gonna tell you about how she's flawed, powerful, empathetic, human, and doesn't take any of Sherlock's shit. She and Jonny Lee Miller (who plays Holmes) have a chemistry that's unique from any adaptation of Sherlock Holmes previous. Elementary takes a boring old story about white dudes that's been told over and over again and switches it up, adding characters of color and trans* characters, and changing white bread John Watson to Joan, a vivacious and fiery character that puts previous incarnations to shame.

edit by raise-youup.tumblr.com - Leading Player, Pippin. I'm gonna take a step back from television for a second and talk about musical theater. Pippin is the kind of show you have to see to really understand, because when I tell you it's a circus-themed musical about Charlemagne's son, you're gonna look at me like I know you're looking at the computer screen right now. The thing is, that's literally what it's about. Pippin (real historical name Pepin) is portrayed as a teen who's just trying to find his way in life (you know, in the Middle Ages where everything is magically a circus) and the Leading Player is the head of the circus troupe that stages the entire show. The Leading Player is a role traditionally played by a man (indeed, Ben Vereen originated the role back in 1972), but when it was revived earlier this year on Broadway, Patina Miller stepped up the play the role. Now the Leading Player is a character somewhat akin to Che in Evita or the Emcee in Cabaret: a character apart from the actual narrative action, who comments on what's going on and guides the protagonist through the plot. But the Leading Player is different than Che or the Emcee in that there's a distinct villainy to the character, and Patina Miller plays this up perfectly. Her Leading Player is nuanced; she's sexy and enticing, manipulative and frightening, comforting while at the same time maintaining her malicious air. She's got a powerhouse voice and perfect command over the complex choreography of the show. She just won a Tony for this role earlier this year, making her and Ben Vereen the first actors of different sexes to win the award for the same character, but between you and me (and the rest of the internet I suppose), it's Patina Miller's portrayal that will be remembered through the years.
- M, James Bond. Okay so I'm a really big James Bond fan. I've been watching the movies since I was a kid, and I turn into a huge fucking dork about them. And while James Bond is not a series generally known for it's fairness to women (god, have you ever read Casino Royale? I only got about halfway through it myself- the Cold War era misogyny was too much handle) but one thing it did right was in Goldeneye, when Judi Dench was brought in to replace a traditionally male role. Judi Dench's M is at first cold and calculating, and while this remains an inherent characteristic of hers, she opens up over the course of her seven films (the second-longest running M, and if you count her video game appearances, she actually has the most appearances of any M ever). She redefines the role of M in more ways than just becoming female. She humanizes M, turning her into a complex character rather than her predecessor's (Robert Brown's) flat portrayal. She also totally calls Bond out on his sexism and misogyny, which is pretty badass, if you ask me. She's my favorite M, hands down. (And this is a bit of an aside, but for anyone who's seen Skyfall, I hope that newly cast Miss Moneypenny- Naomie Harris- will succeed her as the next female M, when Ralph Fiennes eventually passes the torch.)
- Fionna and Cake, Adventure Time. Okay, so the famous genderswap episodes of Adventure Time genderswap everyone, so this particular one isn't solely male-to-female genderswaps, but there's no way I could resist putting this on the list. The Fionna and Cake episodes are just as quirky, funny, and highly intelligent as the rest of Adventure Time is, but everyone is the opposite sex. The first episode has Fionna going on a date with Prince Gumball (don't act like I need to tell you who those characters are) and ending with Fionna proudly declaring that she doesn't need a boyfriend because she's happy just as she is. One of my favorite features of this episode is that there isn't a change besides the sex. Fionna is still a sword-wielding adventurer, and I love that. Seriously, it's everything that's great about Adventure Time but with a genderswap! What more could you want? Nothing, I'm sure.














